A few years ago, I spent an afternoon at a bank branch in San Francisco's Financial District, moving a large placement for a client. The teller asked what I did. I told him I'm a lawyer, and I asked him what I ask almost everyone: when you think of a really good lawyer, who comes to mind?
He named a character from a television show. The second teller named another. They were both young, so I thought little of it until the branch manager, in her forties, came over to sign off on the transaction and named the same two. Then a broker from the commercial side sat down, hoping for our business. He started with Perry Mason, then came back to the first one.
Four people, forty-five minutes, two characters. I have asked the question for years, in conference rooms and at dinner parties, and the answer rarely changes. Pop culture has picked our lawyers for us.
The first is the corporate closer. Tailored suit, corner office overlooking Manhattan. He reads people the way a card sharp reads a table, and he has never, in nine seasons, lost a case that mattered.
The second is scrappier. He started in a mailroom and practiced out of the back of a nail salon. Loud suits, louder billboards, clients in trouble of the criminal variety. The audience roots for him because he came from nothing.
A smaller group describes a type: the pit bull, the lawyer you hire when you want someone hurt.
None of them is the lawyer who keeps a company out of trouble.
Think about a new-car showroom. Polished floors, cars under the lights, good coffee, a loaner waiting. For some jobs, the dealership's service department is exactly where the car belongs. When the transmission needs rebuilding, you want the specialists and their equipment.
Now think about where you actually take your car. The corner garage, the tire shop, the place where they know you by name. When you pull in, the mechanic looks up from under a hood with a sparkle in his eye. He knows you, he knows the car and its history, and he has a fair guess at what's wrong before you say a word.
His lot is full. Every car needs something today, and he does not choose who pulls in. He gets a car, a vague description of a noise, and maybe twenty minutes to figure out what is actually wrong. He knows a little about everything: the brakes, the electrical, the transmission, the tires. He fixes what is broken, and then he tells you what is going to fail next winter if nobody touches it. When the job is too big for his bay, he sends you to the dealership and tells you exactly what to say to the service advisor.
You go back to him for years, because the last time, he told you the truth. Sometimes the truth is an expensive repair that will cost you more if you put it off. Sometimes it is that you don't need the rebuild the dealer quoted, just two parts and an afternoon.
That is the in-house General Counsel. The big firms do the big rebuilds, and they do them well.
Someone still has to know the car.
Trust comes first
You are thirty-two years old, two weeks into your first in-house role at an early-stage pharmaceutical company in the Bay Area. Every morning around eight-thirty, you walk into the break room and make your tea. Four or five people are already there: lab techs, finance staff, line managers.
Then the number two person in the company walks in, the executive vice president of research and development. Brilliant and intimidating. The moment he appears, the room empties. People find urgent reasons to be elsewhere.
You keep making your tea.
You are new, maybe a little naive, and it does not occur to you to leave. You say good morning. He makes his coffee. You talk about the weather, the commute, whether the vending machine will ever stock anything worth eating. This goes on for months.
A year and a half later, he is sitting in your office, confiding a problem that is more personal than professional. Those mornings are what put him there.
The break room works at every company, if you let it. Years later, at a small biotech in Fremont, it is the quarterly potluck. You are reluctant at first to bring samosas. Soon everyone knows exactly what your contribution will be, and they look forward to it. When the board later needs the company behind a difficult decision, that support traces back to a break room and a plate of Indian snacks.
Hearing the noise
At the company that put biotech on the map, your office sits up the hill from the cafeteria, and the path down runs along the jogging route of your boss's boss. Two or three days a week, she finishes her midday jog just as you head down for lunch. Nobody planned it. You were hungry at the same time, so you walk down together. She fires questions at you without warning and in no order: intellectual property, employment law, a contract dispute, a regulatory question she has been turning over for a week. Four areas of the law, in sneakers, with no document in front of you.
She is not a scientist. She is an administrator, married to a scientist, and she knows more about the company's science than most of the scientists working inside their own labs. What she does not know is the law.
For a long time, that intimidates you more than it should. You are not a specialist in any of these areas, and you never claimed to be. You walk back from those jogs worrying whether you said the right thing or the wrong thing.
It takes you a while to remember what you do know. Intellectual property grows out of property law, a first-year class. Contracts, employment, corporate law: you learned the principles in law school and were tested on them for the bar. You have been trained to think in a way most people simply have not. What she wants from those walks, it turns out, is a lawyer's way of thinking about the problem. That you have.
You are listening for which question is urgent, which is serious but stable, and which looks routine today but becomes a crisis in six months.
That is the mechanic's real skill: hearing the noise and knowing which one matters.
Sometimes the fix is getting the right people into one room. At a mid-stage genomics company on the Peninsula, an international licensing deal for the lead drug candidate has been stalled for six months. The CEO, the CFO, the lead patent counsel and the head of sales each see the terms differently. None of them is wrong, and they have never been in the same room at the same time.
After weeks of emails that go nowhere, you call a meeting. You do not book the boardroom. You set up a standing meeting in the cafeteria, Friday afternoons at three. The first week, almost nobody shows. By the third week, staff have noticed senior management meeting in the open, with the lawyer, on a Friday afternoon when everyone else wants to start their weekend. Nobody wants to be the one missing. The deal closes.
Going in, you assume that as the most junior person on that totem pole, you need to know each person's piece as well as they do. You don't. Your job is to gather everyone's ideas and reduce them to one document that holds up. The document is a contract, and contracts you know. Where a clause needs a specialist, you test it with one.
A good corporate lawyer adds to the bottom line every day, by reducing risk or by adding value directly.
Twice now, you have underestimated what you knew.
What the work gives back
Most of the reward is quiet, and you learn that before you are even licensed.
You are twenty-eight, less than two years into the law firm that wired Silicon Valley. Two semiconductor companies are merging. Both CEOs have been in a cavernous conference room all night. Your job is to photocopy contract sections, keep the redlines organized and prepare signature pages. The deal has to close before the market opens in New York.
By dawn, the signatures are done. Someone wheels a television on a cart into the conference room, and the whole team watches the opening bell. The ticker moves. The deal is live. No champagne, just a room full of tired people in wrinkled shirts. It is one of the best mornings of your young career.
Nobody throws the General Counsel a party. If things are working, you are just doing your job.
The showroom gets the lights. The corner garage gets the car that starts every morning for ten years, and the mechanic who is glad to see it pull in.
So the next time someone asks you to picture a great lawyer, who comes to mind?